Updated 18 April 2026 (Originally published 1 May 2023)
This is a list of all chain grocery locations my research has uncovered in Sheboygan between 1924 and 2020, compiled from city directories, telephone books, and other sources. There may be some omissions due to incomplete or missing data, etc. and I welcome suggestions and corrections.
Please read about my methodology for more information about what I do and do not include.
Notes
- The Bensman and Park & Shop stores were all part of the same chain.
Location list
- View or download as: Excel | CSV | PDF | HTML
- 1411 Eastern Av, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1960: A&P
- 1965: A&P
- 1969-70: A&P
- 1975: Piggly Wiggly
- 1980: Piggly Wiggly
- 1985: Piggly Wiggly
- 1990: Piggly Wiggly
- 1996: Piggly Wiggly
- 2000: Piggly Wiggly
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 2015: Piggly Wiggly
- 2020: Piggly Wiggly
- Notes: A&P open ca.1957, closed 1973.
- 2225 Eastern Av, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1990: Sentry
- 1996: Sentry
- 2000: Sentry
- Notes: Closed 2000.
- 2643 Eastern Av, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1996: Park & Save
- 2000: Pick ‘n Save
- 2005: Pick ‘n Save
- 2010: Pick ‘n Save
- 2015: Pick ‘n Save
- 2020: Pick ‘n Save
- 225 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1936: National
- 1940: National
- 1946: IGA?
- 1951: IGA
- 1955: IGA (Bob’s Super)
- 1960: IGA (Bob’s Super)
- 1965: IGA (Bob’s Super)
- Notes: IGA at least by 1947.
- 302 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1946: National
- 1951: National
- Notes: 302-306 (1951).
- 305 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1946: A&P
- 1951: A&P
- 1955: A&P
- Notes: 301 (1955).
- 402 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1924: A&P
- 1930: A&P
- 1936: A&P
- 1940: A&P
- 1951: Royal Blue (Arsenault’s)
- 1955: Royal Blue (Arsenault’s)
- 405 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1940: Kroger
- 1946: Royal Blue (Arsenault’s)
- 414 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1946: Heinecke Co
- 1951: Heinecke Co
- 1955: Heinecke’s
- 506 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1969-70: Red Owl (Bill’s)
- 1975: Red Owl (Bill’s)
- 1980: Red Owl (Bill’s)
- 1985: Red Owl (Bill’s)
- 1990: Bill’s Owlette
- 515 E Mill St, Plymouth | Google Maps Link
- 1969-70: Sentry
- 1975: Sentry
- 1980: Sentry
- 1985: Sentry
- 1990: Sentry
- 715 N 5th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 2331 N 6th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 415 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1924: A&P
- 610 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: Piggly Wiggly
- 1940: Piggly Wiggly
- 1124 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1951: Piggly Wiggly / Diamond Meat Market
- 1225 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1940: A&P
- 1946: A&P
- Notes: 1221 (1946).
- 1427 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1940: John Stephani Co
- 1946: John Stephani Co
- 1817 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1990: Piggly Wiggly
- 1996: Piggly Wiggly
- 2000: Piggly Wiggly
- 2005: Save-A-Lot
- 2010: Save-A-Lot
- 2015: Save-A-Lot
- 2020: Save-A-Lot
- 1833 N 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1951: Krambo
- 1955: Krambo
- 1960: Krambo
- 1965: Krambo
- 1969-70: Kroger
- 1975: Piggly Wiggly
- 1980: Piggly Wiggly
- 1985: Piggly Wiggly
- 823 S 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1965: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1969-70: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1975: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1980: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- Notes: Park & Shop.
- 1501 S 8th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: John Stephani Co
- 1936: John Stephani Co
- 1940: John Stephani Co
- 1946: John Stephani Co
- 1227 S 9th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1924: Valentine Skrube
- 1930: Valentine Skrube
- 1936: Valentine Skrube
- 1940: Valentine Skrube
- 1946: Valentine Skrube
- 1951: Valentine Skrube
- 2128 N 12th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1924: Joseph Bensman
- 1930: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1507 S 12th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: A&P
- 1936: A&P
- 1508 S 12th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1940: John Stephani Co
- 1946: John Stephani Co
- 3010 S 12th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Piggly Wiggly
- 1965: Piggly Wiggly
- 1969-70: Piggly Wiggly
- 1975: Piggly Wiggly
- 1980: Piggly Wiggly
- 1985: Piggly Wiggly
- 710 S 14th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Sentry
- Notes: Opened as Food Basket.
- 1710 N 15th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Red Owl
- Notes: Open late 1955, closed 1963.
- 2905 N 15th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 2015: Piggly Wiggly
- 2020: Piggly Wiggly
- 1725 N 20th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1940: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1946: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1951: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1955: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1960: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1965: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1969-70: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1975: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- 1980: Bensman’s 20th Avenue Food Market
- Notes: 20th and Saemann Av (1930).
- 1317 N 25th St, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1985: Park & Save
- 1990: Park & Save
- 1996: Park & Save
- 2000: Pick ‘n Save
- 2005: Pick ‘n Save
- 2010: Pick ‘n Save
- 2015: Pick ‘n Save
- 2020: Pick ‘n Save
- 1813 Ashland Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1985: Piggly Wiggly
- 1623 Broadway Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1965: Piggly Wiggly
- 1969-70: Piggly Wiggly
- 1975: Piggly Wiggly
- 2421 S Business Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Krambo
- 2625 S Business Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 2015: Pick ‘n Save
- Notes: Former Kmart, closed by 2017.
- 2709 S Business Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1975: Park & Shop
- 1980: Park & Shop?
- 1985: Park & Shop
- 1990: Park & Shop
- 1996: Park & Shop
- 3124 S Business Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 2015: Piggly Wiggly
- 2020: Piggly Wiggly
- 2213 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1990: Pick ‘n Save
- 1996: Pick ‘n Save
- 2000: Pick ‘n Save
- 2005: Pick ‘n Save
- 2010: Pick ‘n Save
- 2643 Eastern Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 2010: Pick ‘n Save
- 2015: Pick ‘n Save
- 2020: Pick ‘n Save
- 1807 Erie Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1955: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1960: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1965: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1969-70: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1975: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- 1980: Bensman’s Park & Shop
- Notes: Park & Shop.
- 805 Indiana Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1946: Heinecke Co
- 1951: Heinecke Co
- 1955: Heinecke Co
- 1129 Indiana Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 2001 Indiana Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 3347 Kohler Memorial Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1975: National
- 3506 Kohler Memorial Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1969-70: Piggly Wiggly
- 1975: Piggly Wiggly
- 1980: Sav-U Warehouse
- 1985: Sav-U Warehouse
- 1339 Mayflower Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1975: Park & Shop
- 1980: Park & Shop
- 1985: Park & Shop
- 1990: Park & Shop
- 1419 Mayflower Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: National
- 1965: National
- 1969-70: National
- 909 Michigan Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1010 Michigan Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1940: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1946: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1951: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1955: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1960: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1965: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1969-70: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- 1975: Bensman’s Michigan Avenue Food Market
- Notes: 1008 (1951 on).
- 1102 Michigan Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1930: Valentine Skrube
- 1232 Michigan Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1924: A&P
- 1930: A&P
- 1936: A&P
- 832 Niagara Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1951: A&P
- 1955: A&P
- 1960: A&P
- 1965: A&P
- 1001 Ontario Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1924: William Bensman
- 1930: William Bensman
- 1936: William Bensman
- 1940: William Bensman
- 1208 Pennsylvania Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1940: John Stephani Co
- 1946: John Stephani Co
- 1434 Superior Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: J Bensman Food Markets
- 1940: Bensman’s Food Market
- 1946: Bensman’s Food Market
- 1951: Bensman’s Food Market
- Notes: 1436 (1951).
- 549 S Taylor Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1990: Piggly Wiggly
- 1996: Piggly Wiggly
- 2000: Piggly Wiggly
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 595 S Taylor Dr, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 2015: Festival Foods
- 2020: Festival Foods
- 1036 Union Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1960: Clover Farm
- 1965: Clover Farm
- 1227 Union Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1951: Piggly Wiggly / Diamond Meat Market
- 1955: Piggly Wiggly / Diamond Meat Market
- 1960: Piggly Wiggly
- 1327 Union Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1946: Heinecke Co
- 1502 Union Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1936: William Bensman
- 1940: William Bensman
- 2219 Wilson Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1990: Piggly Wiggly
- 1996: Piggly Wiggly
- 2000: Piggly Wiggly
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 817 Wisconsin Av, Sheboygan | Google Maps Link
- 1946: Krambo
- 1951: Piggly Wiggly / Diamond Meat Market
- 1955: Piggly Wiggly / Diamond Meat Market
- 1960: Piggly Wiggly
- 1965: Piggly Wiggly
- 1969-70: Piggly Wiggly
- Notes: 815 (1946). 813-817 (1951). 813 (1960 on).
- 714 S Wisconsin Dr, Howard’s Grove | Google Maps Link
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly (Bill’s)
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 2015: Piggly Wiggly
- 2020: Piggly Wiggly
- 1166 Fond du Lac Av, Sheboygan Falls | Google Maps Link
- 2005: Piggly Wiggly
- 2010: Piggly Wiggly
- 2015: Piggly Wiggly
- 2020: Piggly Wiggly
- 122 Pine St, Sheboygan Falls | Google Maps Link
- 1930: A&P